$15 Million for a White Canvas N


15 November 2014

 paintings for sale

 

In a record month for New York art auctions, one standout was an all-white work that sold for $15 million.Even if one lacks Tom Wolfe's courage to doubt the value of contemporary art, the multi-million-dollar price tag for some white paint on canvas cannot but raise existential questions.

White paintings are something of a philosophical tradition. Kazimir Malevich started it in 1918 with "Supermatis Composition: White on White".

 

 

 

 

 

white on white
 

 

 

 

 

Here's what he had to say about it in the catalog for the Moscow exhibition where the cool white square on a warmer white background was first shown:

I have overcome the lining of the colored sky, torn it down and into the bag thus formed, put colour, tying it up with a knot. Swim in the white free abyss, infinity is before you.

American artist Robert Rauschenberg created five "White Paintngs" in 1951. He went further than Malevich in his rejection of substance, simply rolling white house paint onto smooth surfaces.

 

 

 

rauschenberg
 

 

 

 

Composer John Cage, author of the famous piece of silence known as 4'33", described the paintings as landing strips for invisible motes and shadows. Rauschenberg called them clocks:

If one were sensitive enough that you could read it, that you would know how many people were in the room, what time it was, and what the weather was like outside.

Many artists have tried to follow convincingly in Malevich's and Rauschenberg's footsteps, with little success. Muscovite Vladimir Weisberg devoted much of his working life to painting ethereal, mostly geometric shapes in shades of white on white backgrounds. He explaned:

Color exists but it constrains me. It's better when feelings, consciousness, an understanding of truth have a claim on me, I am not afraid to liberate myself from color.

Weisberg's work was too strange for the Soviet Union's tame official art scene, and his first big exhibition took place three years after he died, in 1988. One white-on-white painting, with just a hint of shyly glimmering shapes, sold for $139,280 at Sotheby's in London in 2006. A stitched-together white canvas by Australian-born Lawrence Carroll was valued at between $23,200 and $32,200 at a Sotheby's auction in Milan. It failed to sell.

So what is so special about the 1961 work by American conceptualist Robert Ryman that fetched $15 million in New York this week? Or the nearly identical one below, also by Ryman, which sold for $5.2 million yesterday?

 

 

 

ryman
 

 

 

 

 

It's white in a slightly different way than his predecessors' work, or his own previous oeuvre (he painted his first white canvasses in the 1950s), but it's still, well, white. Ryman's explanation of his fondness for the purest of all colors echoes Rauschenberg's:

White has a tendency to make things visible. With white, you can see more of a nuance; you can see more. I’ve said before that, if you spill coffee on a white shirt, you can see the coffee very clearly. If you spill it on a dark shirt, you don’t see it as well.

The most probable reason for the price lies outside the realm of art, even defined broadly as a symbiosis of painting and explanation. Alexander Rotter, co-head of the contemporary art department at auction house Sotheby's, simply decided that Ryman needed a push. "I thought there was really something to be done with the market, that's why it's been priced so high," the New York Observer quoted him as saying of the untitled painting. "The public needs a great piece to elevate the market and give it an indication of where it could go. The sky is the limit for this painting."

If one wanted to be poetic about this piece of marketing wisdom, one could say Rotter is talking of the same sky whose lining Malevich claimed to have overcome. I'm more inclined to call it cynical. In the end, the value of art is in the emotions it conveys, its power of holding one's eye and occupying one's thoughts. A white canvas may have had the requisite powers in 1918 or even in 1951, because it made a radical statement. In 2014, it's meaningless. The business decision behind the insane price is the only true piece of art in the case of Ryman's works.

Even in the highly unlikely event that certain art lovers are moved by the spectacle of unadulterated whiteness, there's no need to pay millions of dollars for the pleasure. They can simply follow Rauschenberg's advice: "Want one? Paint one."

By

 



« back
Art news
The most expensive paintbrush ever? Florida-based princess uses wind and heat from a private jet's engine to make art
20 January 2015
The most expensive paintbrush ever? Florida-based princess uses wind and heat from a private jet's engine to make art
Princess Tarinan von Anhalt - whose husband was the late Prince Jurgen von Anhalt of Austria - creates art with the help of a very powerful and expensive paintbrush - a jet engine. The Miami, Florida resident gets behind the revving engine of an $11m...
10 Of The Most Wildly Expensive Artworks Sold In 2014
07 January 2015
10 Of The Most Wildly Expensive Artworks Sold In 2014
Money, money, money. Plenty changed hands in the art world this year. As always, contemporary works by white men with cartoon character names -- Warhol, Bacon, Twombly -- made most of the headlines. But while no one's forked over $100 million for a GIF ou...
A 8million Claude Monet original painting has been punched and torn.
16 December 2014
A 8million Claude Monet original painting has been punched and torn.
  Andrew Shannon has been jailed for six years and banned from all galleries - despite claiming he collapsed onto it due to a heart condition. He strolled calmly into the National Gallery of Ireland in Dublin before attacking the 1874 work Arge...
An original painting by Ad Reinhardt has been bought for $375 000 and sold for $5 million.
10 December 2014
An original painting by Ad Reinhardt has been bought for $375 000 and sold for $5 million.
The artwork, known as "Blue Painting," has been sold in less than an hour at the Art Basel fair in Switzerland for between $5 million and $10 million, according to reports. Cyrus Greenspon claims in court papers that her step-sister's mega-chea...
Creating Art Using BMW
09 December 2014
Creating Art Using BMW
Who knew that the BMW i8 could be used to create art? While some call the car itself a piece of art from an engineering and visual point of view, others see it as ugly. We’re here to tell you that the meaning of the word has been somehow diluted ...
Titian  D
28 November 2014
Titian D
  Such an attitude toward religious subjects was safe enough, for the Inquisition was not allowed to operate within the territory of the Venetian Republic. If there was any censoring of morals to be done, the doges intended to do it themselves, and ...
$45 bargain at a Garage Sale turns into an estimated $200 Millions treasure now N
20 November 2014
$45 bargain at a Garage Sale turns into an estimated $200 Millions treasure now N
  Sometimes hunting for a bargain at a garage sales pays off . 10 years ago Rick Norsigian bought 2 small boxes at a garage sale for $45 down from $70. Now according to  an art appraiser in Beverly Hills, those 2 boxes containing 65 glass n...
The Painting Bought for $46 Turned Out to be a Constable Worth $390,000 N
19 November 2014
The Painting Bought for $46 Turned Out to be a Constable Worth $390,000 N
    A postcard-sized painting that was bought as part of a job lot for $46 (£30) at an auction and left hidden away in a drawer for a decade has been identified as a work by John Constable worth more than $390,000 (£250,000). ...
 $15 Million for a White Canvas  N
15 November 2014
$15 Million for a White Canvas N
    In a record month for New York art auctions, one standout was an all-white work that sold for $15 million.Even if one lacks Tom Wolfe's courage to doubt the value of contemporary art, the multi-million-dollar price tag for some ...
6 Richest Painters In The World  N
12 November 2014
6 Richest Painters In The World N
Searching for the richest painters in the world can prove a rather difficult task, as many of these artists don’t want you to know how much they’re worth, or truly don’t know or care about finding out their own actual wealth; they&r...
« view all news